You are Not a Church! You are a Store!

I have some pychocrafting tendencies. In my part of the country, that means I shop a fair amount at Hobby Lobby. I shop there primarily because they sell decent stuff for cheap.

If you follow the news of the healthcare or crafting world, you know that Hobby Lobby (and sister company Mardel) sued the federal government because the owners don’t want to have to comply with the new insurance mandates. Under “Obamacare,” as it is commonly known, health insurance must now cover birth control and the “morning after pill.” Employers can apply for an exemption to the rules on religious grounds if that employer is a church or something like that. Those rules are getting tighter as well. You can’t just say, “Oh, we’re religious. We don’t want to follow the rules.” The long and the short of it is, you pretty much have to be performing sacraments to get a religious exemption. Quite frankly, I’m good with that. It makes sense to me.

I realize there are people who will want to argue the point, but as a matter of medical science, the morning after pill does not cause an abortion. It prevents pregnancy. Now there are some religious groups who believe anything that interferes with conception is against God’s plan. I don’t personally subscribe to the theology, but I get where they’re coming from. If you are a church with that belief system, it makes sense you would be exempt. What Hobby Lobby, the arts and crafts store, is arguing is that they are the same as a church, and should not have to comply with the new laws because it violates their religion.

Believe it or not, people are taking this argument seriously: Hobby Lobby is a “Christian” company. It has something to do with being closed on Sundays and playing hymns over their sound system. But here’s the thing. I know they’re not a church. I know this because I have gone in their doors, walked around with a shopping cart and purchased things.

While we’re on the subject, most of the things that I purchase are made in China. Others are made in Pakistan. Those aren’t exactly evangelical strongholds. You know why they’re made there? Because they don’t have fair and just labor laws and environmental standards. I could make things a lot cheaper too if I could use the slave labor of small children or political prisoners and didn’t care what destruction I heaped on God’s creation. Pretty sure there’s a verse or two in the Bible about those things. But they don’t choose to care about those parts of being Christian. Just this one. I suspect it has a lot to do with how much the premiums on their insurance will go up, and less to do with God’s divine law. Call me a cynic.

But even more than that, I take issue with a for-profit company claiming any religion. Are the stocks baptized? Do the bonds take communion? Are all employees screened with a religion test? How do they judge another person’s heart? It’s just absurd on its face.

Let me be clear: I have every reason to believe the owners of this company are devout people. Good for them. I really do mean that. They claim to run their company with “Christian” principles. I believe they run their company through the lens of Christianity that they understand. And that’s the very point. When people who claim the same God cannot even agree on what constitutes “Christian” business principles, how can our secular government be expected to parse that out? It must then treat all for-profit companies the same and hold them to the same standards.

Fortunately, a judge in Oklahoma City saw some clarity on this issue when he ruled earlier this month, “Hobby Lobby and Mardel are not religious organizations.” U.S. District Judge Joe Heaton wrote, “the court is not unsympathetic” to the issues that were raised in the case. But ultimately, retail stores don’t get to pass themselves off as churches. The real religion they’re selling is consumerism.

The company will appeal. No doubt martyrs and demons will be cast as this plays out. I find myself again in the uncomfortable position of wondering if it’s possible to buy only American-made products, if that’s even a useful goal and how I should or could be a Christian to the children who work in the factories in China who make the stuff I like to buy.

I know without a doubt I should buy less of as much stuff as I can. I should recycle, reuse, upcycle and restore all that I can to reduce demand. That makes me a good steward of my dollars and the environment. But quite frankly, so much of this is beyond my buying power. It would help, even if just a little, if companies who claimed to be “Christian” companies (whatever that means) would think about these things too.



Filed under The view from here

16 responses to “You are Not a Church! You are a Store!

  1. Let the Hobby Lobby Church say, “Amen.”

  2. Love this! You put so well into words exactly what’s been frusterating me so much about all the anit-“Obamacare” zealots, the “Christian” organization who want to cherry pick the “benefits” being a religious orgainzation affords them, and how all of a sudden they’re all, “Oh but we’re CHRISTIAN organization!” Well why aren’t you b*tching that you should be tax exempt? Because you know that’s rediculous. Your title says it perfectly, YOU ARE NOT A CHURCH, YOU ARE A STORE! Love it.

  3. Mike

    I tend to agree with the Judge. Lots of people legitimately do not like the law for some very valid reasons. That, however, is not the basis for a lawsuit to avoid complying with the law.

  4. I was honestly surprised when the judge ruled that way, since other cases have not ended out like that. I hope that when they appeal, it is a historic case that will continue to be used to protect workers from “religiosity.”

  5. I once worked in Mardel’s main competitor, Family Christian Stores. At the time, I can assure you, they were a store. They disappointed me regularly with the bottom-line-only attitude they had. They recently bought themselves from the equity firm that owned them, and have now pledged to give all profits to organizations that help widows and orphans. THAT is how you can be a business that operates in a Christian manner.

  6. I’m reminded of this little ditty from the King James Bible (Cambridge Ed.) ~
    “And Jesus went into the temple of God, and cast out all them that sold and bought in the temple, and overthrew the tables of the moneychangers, and the seats of them that sold doves,” I believe they have dove statues at Hobby Lobby.

  7. Sara

    This is one of your finest posts! Here here!

  8. thebrokins

    I love this and you. Good stuff Kerri!

  9. Angela

    Saw your post but have to correct you here. Even those performing sacraments can’t get an exemption. Because the Catholic Church serves all people, regardless of creed, they can’t get the religious exemption. So the sacraments don’t count to Sebelius and her crew, no surprise. Hence the reason so many fellow Americans feel slighted and like they’re being forced by the regime to comply. Doesn’t feel quite “American”, does it?

    • As I understand it, the church itself does in fact get the exemption. Those that are loosely associated with the church do not. For example, if you work for the Catholic diocese, your insurance is exempt. If you work for a hospital that has a loose affiliation with the Catholic church, but gets the bulk of its funding from Medicaid and Medicare, then you are not exempt.

    • The Catholic Church most certainly does NOT serve all people regardless of creed! That is a LIE! If you are Gay you are turned away, if you are gay and have kids they are turned away! Sacraments are denied regularly to these people and any NON Catholic! So Just save the hate and anti Oboma lies for another place!

  10. rebecca

    AMEN! (tongue in cheek). Thank you for your post. Intelligent, pragmatic and well thought out.

  11. Fred F.

    I wonder if the verdict would be different if the company’s current health insurance provider does not cover birth control nor the “morning after” pill? The fact that they are “forced” to change their insurance to cover this? Hmmm Not trying to debate, but if their insurance “reflex’s” their religious beliefs?

  12. Pingback: At the Intersection of Hobbies and Personal Beliefs, Belief Prevails on Both Sides – About | Pregnancy Week Guide